Why Turkey Should Not Join the European Union

Why Turkey

 

foreign-correspondent badge finalEHSo my boyfriend and I had this crazy idea that we should go to Istanbul for New Year’s Eve after spending Christmas in Rome. We arrived with a certain set of ideas about what Turkey would be like and ended up leaving with a completely different perception of not only the city, but also the country itself.

Living in Milan, I often hear Italians discussing the happenings of the European Union, which inevitably leads to the subject of Turkey’s possible inclusion. From my American point of view, I have always maintained that this would be a wonderful opportunity for the EU, not just economically but geographically as well. Turkey’s acceptance would stretch the borders of the European Union literally into another continent. I was so supportive of this idea that I even wrote a paper about it in college, advocating for the European Union to acknowledge this amazing opportunity that it seemed to just let sit in front of it. After having visited Turkey though, and spent some time there, I have to say that my views on this matter have changed.

Why Turkey

Why Turkey Should Not Join the European Union

First off, when studying Turkish society, I have always read that it is a heterogeneous one with a variety of religions customs, foods, etc. Given that it was once the capital of the Roman Empire under Constantine and then later incorporated into the Ottoman Empire under Sultan Mehmed II of the Ottoman Turks, it is easy to see how this cultural mixture might exist. However, after having visited Istanbul and stayed in the ?i?li (pronounced ‘Shishli’) neighborhood, famed for being the more modern, European part of Istanbul, I have to say that I definitely did not feel like I was still in Europe.

Istanbul is called ‘The Gateway between East and West’ because the city is divided by the Bosphorus into what is known as the European and the Asian sides. Though we spent most of our time on the European side the constant aroma of kofte, kebab, sahlep and baklawa made me feel as if I was in a different world, in the best possible way. Many will protest that I am already living the dream having a job and apartment in Milan, but it was oh-so-hard to say goodbye to that beautiful, aromatic city when I had only the gray, rainy skies of Milan to welcome me back.

Why Turkey Should Not Join the European Union

But back to Turkey and the European Union. The objective that I am trying to illustrate here is that, as hard as it is for me to say it, Turkey should not join the European Union. My reasons are two-fold; one, even on the European side of Turkey, it is ever apparent that this is not Europe, or at least the idea of Europe that the EU is trying to create; two, Turkey’s economy is doing splendidly. There was construction everywhere and where there is construction, there is money. Were Turkey to join the EU, I would predict that it would only be dragged down by the current state of economic affairs within the Union. In short, Turkey doesn’t need the EU; it has an economy and society all its own that is unlike anything I have seen in my many years of traveling.

Why Turkey Should Not Join the European Union

About L. Gabrielle Castagno

AvatarGabrielle Castagno began traveling at the age of 16, and has been hooked ever since. Gabrielle has ventured to over 9 different countries, most recently residing in Milan, Italy where she was an ESL teacher. She now works with a refugee resettlement agency in Dallas, Texas and is involved with numerous human rights initiatives throughout the US. A dual Italian-American citizen, Gabrielle hopes to return to Italy soon, to work with refugees there.

3 thoughts on “Why Turkey Should Not Join the European Union

  1. Avatar
    Stefano
    July 19, 2015
    Reply

    Not completely agree with this. The idea itself of Europe is based on diversity. You live in Italy right? If you take a train from Milan to Naples you will travel through countless Italys. Italy is not a clear, defined idea. Italy is made of so many different faces. Same with Europe. Denmark and Greece come from completely, totally different cultures, for example. Turkey joining EU is just a very complicated issue. I am agree though with the beauty of Istanbul. A magic, fantastic, charming city.

  2. Avatar
    Emre
    February 21, 2014
    Reply

    “Though we spent most of our time on the European side the constant aroma of kofte, kebab, sahlep and baklawa made me feel as if I was in a different world, in the best possible way. Many will protest that I am already living the dream having a job and apartment in Milan, but it was oh-so-hard to say goodbye to that beautiful, aromatic city when I had only the gray, rainy skies of Milan to welcome me back.”

    Please do not take it as offense, Milan is a very nice city, but last summer I was in Milan for a few days and I could not wait to return back to Istanbul. Istanbul (and Turkey as a whole) is lively!

  3. Avatar
    Emre
    February 21, 2014
    Reply

    I am a Turk and I do not want my country to join the EU. EU is going into a very dark era, economically, politically and culturally, ie. In every aspect that can be taken into consideration. This dark era has started and it will get darker and darker with time, the main reason being demographics. EU countries are old nations, the average ages of people in these populations are very high. Birth rates are low. EU nations are dying slowly, there is not enough young generation to carry the flags of culture, economy, production, technology, knowledge…EU has started to lose its political importance and influence in the world, and because of the aforementioned reasons, it will continue to lose more with increasing momentum. Turkey however, is one of the youngest and most dynamic nations in the world, a fastly growing population with better education, able to produce, open to economic growth, able to do cultural interactions with all the world, able to accumulate knowledge and know-how. Just like companies, the most important asset of a country is its people. EU is losing its human-power which can be replaced by nothing else in the world. Turkey has a bright future, it should stay away from the EU, it should continue to invest more in education and R&D, and if it will seek partnerships it should do so with China, Brasil, India, Indonesia and similar countries which have a future.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Top
Loading...